Essence Lash Princess Waterproof Eyeliner Pen - Vegan & Cruelty-Free Black Liquid Eyeliner | Perfect for Daytime Wear, Night Out Makeup & Long-Lasting Eye Looks

Bought this summer to use at my daughter’s wedding. It stayed put during tears and 90°weather!HIGHLY RECOMMENDI’m 65 and it is ridiculously easy to use, no pulling at your eye, just a smooth fluid line.However,Top line-from Amazon, seemed to be a weak line unless I applied pressure.Bottom line-bought at ULTA today, seems to be, “fresher”, very easy to use and fluid.*I wonder if it sat in a warehouse, or what happened, it seems to be dried out. Almost like a pen running out of ink.